3 Tab vs Architectural Shingles: Which is Better?

If you’re building a new house or considering a roof replacement, you may be wondering, “Which shingles should I use?” Likely, you’ve come across two types: 3-tab shingles and architectural asphalt shingles.

Navigating the world of roofing can feel overwhelming. You know there are benefits to discover – savings, durability, aesthetics – but understanding these can be complex.

Every homeowner has unique needs, and each roofing material has specific advantages. We’re here to clarify these key elements – cost, lifespan, and differences between 3-tab and architectural asphalt shingle roofs – to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding the Basics of Shingle Roofing

Roof shingles, a common choice for American homes, are small rectangular pieces that layer together to form a barrier against weather. Two popular types you’ll often see are 3-Tab shingles and architectural asphalt shingles.

These types differ in design and performance. 3-Tab shingles have three tabs per piece, giving roofs a uniform pattern. They’re lightweight but still offer solid protection from elements.

The other type is architectural asphalt shingle – sometimes called dimensional or laminate shingle. It’s layered to give depth and dimension like wood shake roofs do, providing an appealing aesthetic while being durable.

Factors Influencing Choice

Your decision between these two might depend on various factors, including budget constraints, desired look, or lifespan expectancy for your roof. Our team at Fidelity Roofing can guide you through this process based on our extensive experience with residential roofing systems in Newton, NC.

Durability & Cost Effectiveness 

  • Durable options may cost more upfront but save money in the long term because they require less maintenance.
  • If initial costs concern you, choosing cheaper alternatives such as 3-Tab could be practical.
  • Balancing durability with affordability helps ensure wise investment into your home’s future value.

This should help set up an understanding of what comes next: deeper dives into both kinds of roofing.

A Deep Dive into 3-Tab Shingles

As a top choice for homeowners, 3-tab shingles offer unique benefits. However, these shingles do have their drawbacks.

The Structure of 3-Tab Shingles

True to its name, each piece has three tabs or cutouts along the lower edge, making it look like three separate pieces when installed. This design allows for uniform and orderly patterns on your roof.

The Benefits: Cost and Simplicity

Known for being cost-effective, these shingles are affordable compared to other roofing materials. Plus, they’re simple to install—making them a favorite among DIY enthusiasts.

The Drawbacks: Durability and Lifespan

All isn’t rosy in the world of 3-tab shingle roofing, though. These shingles can be less durable than architectural asphalt shingles under harsh weather conditions because they’re thinner by comparison.

As you consider options for your home’s crown (the roof.), weigh these pros and cons against what works best within your budget and aesthetic preferences.

An In-depth Look at Architectural Asphalt Shingles

Architectural asphalt shingles, dimensional or laminate shingles, have a distinct edge in the roofing world. Why? Let’s explore.

Durable and Weather Resistant

These bad boys are tough. Fidelity Roofing installs architectural asphalt shingles made from multiple layers of material that add weight and durability. They resist high winds, heavy rain, and extreme temperatures better than 3-tab singles.

Aesthetically Pleasing Design

If your roof could strut on a runway, it would with these shingles. The multi-dimensional look gives depth to your roof, making it more appealing. It can mimic natural slate or wood shake roofs without breaking the bank.

Lifespan: Longevity for Peace of Mind

You want longevity in love life and roofing – the good news is we’ve got you covered (pun intended) with the latter. Typically lasting 25-30 years, depending on environmental factors, architectural asphalt outlives its counterpart by nearly double.

Note: Do remember – all materials need proper installation to perform their best.

Cost Comparison between 3-Tab and Architectural Asphalt Shingles

Suppose you’re considering a new roof; price matters. It’s not just about the initial cost but also long-term value. Let’s compare the costs of two popular choices: 3-tab shingles and architectural asphalt shingles.

On average, 3-tab shingles are cheaper upfront – typically costing around $0.80 to $1.50 per square foot (Roofing Calc). But that’s only part of the story.

Architectural asphalt shingles have a higher starting point at roughly $1.50 to $5.50 per square foot (Home Guide). This includes material costs and installation expenses, so why would anyone go with these more expensive options?

The answer lies in durability and maintenance costs over time which we’ll get into later sections of this post.

A well-installed roof using quality architectural asphalt can last up to twice as long as a comparable 3-tab one. Over decades, those savings have added up big-time when considering replacement intervals.

Balancing affordability against longevity, aesthetics, and peace of mind is a difficult decision to make when selecting roofing materials.

Durability Comparison between 3-Tab and Architectural Asphalt Shingles

When it comes to roofing, durability is a top priority. Let’s pit the two popular choices – 3-tab shingles and architectural asphalt shingles against each other.

Weather Resistance of 3-Tab vs Architectural Shingles

Architectural asphalt shingles are beefier compared to their three-tab counterparts. They stand up better in extreme weather conditions due to their layered structure. In contrast, three-tabs might struggle with high winds or heavy snowfall.

Lifespan: The Longevity Battle

In terms of lifespan, architectural asphalt again has an edge over 3-tab. On average, it can last for about 30 years, while a typical three-tab roof lasts around 20 years only. That’s quite a difference.

The Wear-and-Tear Showdown

Wear-and-tear affects every roof type, but how much? Well, here, too, architectural asphalts take the lead because they resist curling and color fading more effectively than the traditional three-tabs do.

Remember, folks at Fidelity Roofing, we’ve got your back when you need help choosing what’s best for your home.

Aesthetic Differences between 3-Tab and Architectural Asphalt Shingles

Regarding the looks, there’s a clear difference between 3-tab and architectural asphalt shingles. The former has a simple, flat appearance with clean lines that can give your home an uncluttered look. But some might find them too plain.

On the other hand, architectural shingles are all about depth and dimension. Their design mimics the high-end look of wood or slate roofs without the large price tag. This HGTV article gives you more insight into their unique appeal.

If we compare both on curb appeal alone, many homeowners lean towards architectural shingles because they offer various color schemes and textures.

  • Color Variety: While 3-tab options come in fewer colors than their counterpart.
  • Different Textures: With multi-layer construction allowing for random notches, tabs, and shadow bands, architectural types create dynamic shadows that make them seem thicker.

If you’re looking for versatility and elegance to elevate your home’s exterior aesthetic, consider going with architectural asphalt shingles.

Making the Right Choice for Your Home

Choosing between 3-tab and architectural asphalt shingles can be tricky. Deciding between 3-tab and architectural asphalt shingles is akin to selecting a favorite ice cream flavor; both have their advantages, yet the choice comes down to personal preference.

Consider what matters most to you. If cost is your main concern, 3-tab shingles are generally more affordable upfront. But remember long-term costs too. Maintenance and replacement expenses over time might tip the scales in favor of architectural asphalt shingles.

If durability ranks high on your list, architectural asphalt may win out with its more rigid build and longer lifespan. Picture this: it’s like comparing an SUV to a compact car regarding robustness.

  • Aesthetic appeal: Which style makes you feel prouder when showing off your home? Architectural has that dimensional charm, while 3-tab provides clean lines.
  • Weighing preferences: Like choosing between hiking or beach vacation – one isn’t necessarily better than the other; they’re just different.

Remember, at Fidelity Roofing, we help customers make informed decisions by inspecting all residential roofing systems before installation.

So go ahead. Choose wisely, knowing each type brings unique benefits.


We’ve explored the differences between 3-tab and architectural asphalt shingles to help you decide about your roof.

3-tab shingles are cheaper upfront but may not hold up against severe weather or architectural shingles. While architectural asphalt shingles cost more initially, they offer superior durability and a visually pleasing dimensional look.

It would help if you decided what’s most important: saving money upfront or having a durable, long-lasting roof. Do you prefer basic functionality or an attractive exterior?

The answer to “Which is better: 3-tab shingle or architectural asphalt shingles?” depends on your needs and preferences.

  • Fidelity Roofing, Inc
  • 1725 McRee Rd., Newton, North Carolina 28658
  • Monday - Friday: 9:00am - 5:00pm
  • Saturday, Sunday: Closed
Scroll to Top